Quick comparison
| Spirit | Main ingredient | Usually aged in oak? | Typical bottling strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whiskey | Grain: barley, corn, rye or wheat | Usually, though not always | Commonly 40% to 46%; cask strength is higher |
| Rum | Sugarcane products, such as molasses or cane juice | Often, but not always | Often around 40%; overproof rums are higher |
| Brandy | Wine or fermented fruit, most often grapes | Often | Often around 40% |
| Vodka | Grain, potato or other starch | Usually not | At least 40% in the US; at least 37.5% in the EU |
Whiskey vs rum
Whiskey is made from grain. Rum is made from sugarcane products, such as molasses or fresh cane juice. Those raw materials lead to different flavours. Whiskey tends toward cereal, caramel, vanilla and oak. Rum varies much more widely by style and origin, and can lean toward sugarcane sweetness, spice or fruit.
Rum’s strength varies too. Many rums are bottled at around 40%, but the range is wide, and overproof rums go well above that. So the answer to “is rum 40% alcohol?” is often yes, but not always.
Whiskey vs brandy and bourbon
Brandy is distilled from fermented fruit, most often grapes. Cognac and Armagnac are grape brandies from France. Calvados is an apple brandy from Normandy, sometimes made with pears. Brandy tends to taste fruitier and softer than whiskey, with dried fruit, honey and floral notes. For a direct comparison, see whether whiskey or brandy is better.
Bourbon is not a separate spirit from whiskey. It is a type of American whiskey. In the United States, bourbon must be made from a mash of at least 51% corn, distilled to no more than 160 proof, and aged in new charred oak containers. Straight bourbon must be aged for at least two years. Bourbon tends to taste sweeter and richer than other whiskeys, with vanilla, caramel and toffee notes. For the full rules, see bourbon vs whiskey.
Whiskey vs vodka
Vodka is made to be neutral. In the United States, the neutral spirit used for vodka is distilled to 190 proof (95% ABV) or higher, which strips out most of the grain’s character. US rules describe vodka as having no distinctive character, aroma or taste. Whiskey is distilled to a lower strength to keep the grain flavour, and it is usually aged in wood. For a closer look at the difference, see is unaged whiskey just vodka.
Alcohol percentage: what is typical
Most whiskies, rums, brandies and vodkas on shelves are bottled at around 40% ABV. Scotch must be bottled at no less than 40%, and US whiskey at no less than 80 proof, which is also 40%. Vodka’s US minimum is 40%, and the EU minimum is 37.5%.
Cask-strength and barrel-proof whiskies are bottled without being diluted to a standard strength, and they are often 50% ABV or higher. Some rums and other spirits are stronger still. A higher number on the label means a stronger drink, not a better one.
Reading ABV and proof
ABV is the percentage of alcohol by volume. In the United States, proof is double the ABV, so 40% ABV is 80 proof. Many UK and EU labels show ABV alone.
The strength on a label tells you the alcohol content of the bottle, not how many standard drinks it holds. What counts as a standard drink differs by country, so check local guidance if you are tracking how much you drink.
Which should you choose?
Choose by flavour and by how you plan to drink it. Whiskey suits drinkers who like grain, oak and spice. Rum suits those who enjoy sugarcane sweetness and a wide range of styles. Brandy suits drinkers who want fruit and a mellow finish. Vodka suits those who want a clean base with little flavour. A simple check is the cocktails you already order, since the spirit in those drinks is usually the one you already enjoy. For whiskey-based drinks, see the best whiskey for cocktails.
For the main styles of whisky itself, see the main types of whisky.