Choosing, Storing and Serving

Best Whiskey for Cocktails: Whiskey Sour, Bourbon Sour and Old Fashioned

Which whiskey to use in a whiskey sour, bourbon sour and Old Fashioned, whether a sour is served up or on the rocks, and common mistakes to avoid.

On this page
  1. Whiskey sour: served up or on the rocks?
  2. Whiskey sour vs. bourbon sour
  3. Old Fashioned: bourbon or rye?
  4. Which whiskey for which drink
  5. Do you need a top-shelf bottle for mixing?
  6. Common mistakes
  7. Recipes and next steps

The right whiskey depends on the drink. Bourbon tends to make sweeter, rounder cocktails. Rye tends to be spicier and drier. Scotch and Japanese whisky each bring their own character, which can suit a highball. This guide answers the most common questions about sours and Old Fashioneds, then matches styles to drinks.

Whiskey sour: served up or on the rocks?

Both are common, and neither is wrong. A whiskey sour is usually shaken with lemon juice and sugar, then strained.

  • Served up. Strained into a chilled coupe or stemmed glass. This is the classic serve, and it is often used with egg white, which gives a frothy top. Serving up also keeps the drink cold without ice diluting it as you sip.
  • On the rocks. Strained over fresh ice in a rocks glass. It is more casual and very common in bars and at home.

If the drink has egg white, serve it up. Otherwise, choose the glass you enjoy more.

Whiskey sour vs. bourbon sour

A whiskey sour can be made with any whiskey. A bourbon sour is a whiskey sour made with bourbon. The base recipe is the same: about 2 oz whiskey, 3/4 oz fresh lemon juice and 3/4 oz simple syrup. Some recipes add an egg white or a cherry garnish.

Whiskey sour Bourbon sour
Base spirit Any whiskey Bourbon
Typical flavour Depends on the whiskey. Rye is spicier, and smoky Scotch stands out. Usually sweeter, with vanilla and caramel notes.

Old Fashioned: bourbon or rye?

The Old Fashioned is built on whiskey, and bourbon or rye are the usual choices. Most recipes use sugar or syrup, bitters, a little water, ice and an orange peel. Bourbon makes a rounder, sweeter drink with vanilla and caramel notes. Rye makes a drier, spicier one. The choice comes down to taste. For more on how the two differ, see rye whiskey vs bourbon.

Which whiskey for which drink

Drink Good starting style Why
Whiskey sour Bourbon or rye Bourbon is rounder. Rye adds spice.
Old Fashioned Bourbon or rye The same trade-off applies.
Manhattan Rye or bourbon Rye is the classic choice. Bourbon is softer.
Highball Japanese, Scotch, bourbon or rye A light, clean whisky suits soda. Smoky Scotch stands out.
Mint julep Bourbon Its sweetness holds up to mint, sugar and ice.

Do you need a top-shelf bottle for mixing?

Usually not. Sugar, citrus and bitters change a drink’s flavour a lot, so a mid-range bottle is often enough. Save your best bottles for sipping, where the whisky’s own flavour is the star. Taste a whisky neat first, then decide whether its character will come through in a cocktail.

Common mistakes

  • Shaking an Old Fashioned. Shaking makes it cloudy and over-diluted. Stir it with good ice instead.
  • Too much sugar. Start with less syrup and adjust. Bourbon is already sweet and can need a little less syrup than rye.
  • Old ice. Use fresh, cold ice. Tray ice that has sat in the freezer can taste of it.
  • Skipping the taste test. Taste the drink before you serve it, then adjust the citrus or sweetener.

Recipes and next steps

For full recipes, see:

If you are out of sweet and sour mix, see what to use in place of sweet and sour mix.

Drink responsibly and in moderation.

The complete guide to choosing, storing and serving

How to Choose a Whisky: Premium Brands and Best Sellers
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →