Choosing, Storing and Serving

Is sour mash whiskey the same as bourbon whiskey?

Sour mash is not always bourbon. Bourbon is a legal category, while sour mash is a fermentation method. Learn the rules, the overlap and how to check a label.

On this page
  1. What makes a whiskey bourbon
  2. What sour mash means
  3. Where the two overlap
  4. Does sour mash change the taste?
  5. How to check a bottle

Sour mash is not always bourbon. Bourbon is a legal category with specific rules. Sour mash is a production method. Most bourbon uses it, but the law does not require it, and some sour mash whiskey does not meet the rules for bourbon at all.

What makes a whiskey bourbon

In the United States, bourbon must meet several legal rules:

  • It is produced in the United States.
  • Its mash is at least 51% corn.
  • It is aged in new, charred oak containers.
  • It enters the barrel at no more than 125 proof (62.5% ABV) and is distilled to no more than 160 proof (80% ABV).
  • It is bottled at no less than 80 proof (40% ABV).
  • Nothing is added except water to adjust the proof, so no colouring or flavouring.

“Straight bourbon” also requires at least two years of ageing. The rules are set by US regulation, and the method used to ferment the mash is not one of them.

What sour mash means

Sour mash is a fermentation method. Distillers add acidic liquid left over from a previous distillation, called backset or stillage, to a new batch of mash before fermentation. The acidity helps control bacteria and supports the yeast, and it can help keep the flavour consistent from batch to batch.

Despite the name, sour mash whiskey does not taste sour. The opposite method is sweet mash, which uses fresh water and no backset for each batch.

Where the two overlap

  • Sour mash bourbon. Made with the sour mash method and meets all the bourbon rules. This is common.
  • Sweet mash bourbon. Made with fresh water and still counts as bourbon.
  • Sour mash whiskey that is not bourbon. Uses the sour mash method but fails a bourbon rule. It may use less than 51% corn, or it may be aged in used barrels rather than new ones.

Does sour mash change the taste?

Opinions are mixed. Many distillers value sour mash mainly for consistency. Some drinkers say they can taste a difference, but many can’t. Flavour is shaped more by the grain recipe, the barrels, the age and the strength. Historically, sour mash helped early distillers keep fermentation steady when sanitation and yeast science were less advanced. Today the method is mostly about consistency, not a reliable guide to taste.

How to check a bottle

  • The label. Look for “bourbon” on the front and check the back for the grain recipe, barrel details and age.
  • The producer’s website. Many producers explain their grain recipe and whether they use sour or sweet mash.
  • The legal term. If a bottle says “bourbon,” it meets the rules above. If it says only “sour mash whiskey,” check the grain recipe and barrel details before assuming it is bourbon.

For more on styles and label terms, see how to choose a whisky.

The complete guide to choosing, storing and serving

How to Choose a Whisky: Premium Brands and Best Sellers
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →