Fresh lemon or lime juice and simple syrup, in roughly equal parts, is the simplest substitute for sweet and sour mix. Adjust it to taste. Other options include honey or maple syrup as the sweetener, bottled lime juice, or lemonade in a pinch.
What sweet and sour mix is
Sweet and sour mix is usually a blend of sugar and acid, often citric acid, with added flavour. Some versions are based on lemon or lime juice, and others are powdered or concentrated. Because it is both sweet and sour, a homemade version made with fresh juice and syrup can cover much of the same role in a whiskey drink.
Quick substitute: fresh citrus and simple syrup
Mix equal parts fresh lemon or lime juice and simple syrup. For a single whiskey sour, that is about 3/4 oz of each, with about 2 oz of whiskey. Shake with ice, taste, and adjust. Some people start with a little less syrup and add more once they have tasted the drink.
How to make simple syrup
Stir equal parts sugar and hot water until the sugar dissolves, then let it cool. Store it in a sealed container in the fridge. It keeps for a few weeks.
Other swaps
- Honey or maple syrup. Use either in place of simple syrup. A honey syrup is usually made with equal parts honey and hot water. Maple adds a deeper, woody flavour.
- Bottled lime juice. Shelf-stable and handy. Fresh juice tastes brighter, so use it when you can, and check the label for added sugar.
- Lemonade. Sweeter and less tart than a sour mix base. It works in a pinch, but cut back on the other sweetener and taste before adding more.
- Orange juice. Sweeter and softer. Add a little lemon or lime to balance it. It works in some whiskey drinks but changes the flavour.
How to adjust the balance
Taste the drink before you serve it. If it is too sweet, add a little citrus. If it is too sour, add a little syrup. Change one thing at a time, and keep notes if you are making several drinks. Shake with ice for about 15 seconds so the drink is well chilled and mixed.
For a whiskey sour without any lemon, see can you make a whiskey sour without lemon? For more drink ideas, see whiskey for cocktails.