Yes. You can make a whiskey sour without lemon by swapping in another citrus, most often lime. The sour comes from acid, so the swap works best when it keeps a similar level of tartness. A drink with no citrus at all is a different style of drink rather than a sour.
Why a sour needs acid
A whiskey sour balances three things: the whiskey, a sweetener and a sour element. Lemon juice supplies the acid, and the sweetener, usually simple syrup, rounds it out. If you change the acid, you change the balance, so taste as you go.
Best citrus swaps
- Lime juice. The closest swap. Use it one-for-one in place of lemon. Lime is slightly sharper and more aromatic, so you may want a touch less syrup.
- Orange juice or marmalade. Sweeter and softer. Add a squeeze of lime or a dash of bitters if it tastes too sweet. Marmalade is very sweet, so use it sparingly.
- Grapefruit juice. Works in some sours. It is more bitter, which changes the drink noticeably, so test a small batch first.
- Bottled lime juice. Shelf-stable and handy in a pinch, though fresh juice tastes brighter.
Quick no-lemon bourbon sour
This makes one drink.
- 2 oz bourbon or rye
- 3/4 oz fresh lime juice
- 1/2 to 3/4 oz simple syrup, maple syrup or honey syrup
- Optional: 1/2 oz egg white, or 2 to 3 dashes Angostura bitters
- If you are using egg white, shake all the ingredients without ice for about 10 seconds first.
- Add ice and shake for 15 to 20 seconds.
- Strain into a chilled coupe, or into a rocks glass over fresh ice.
- Garnish with a lime wheel or a cherry if you have one.
Make it with orange
Orange juice gives a softer, sweeter drink. Use about 3/4 oz orange juice with a small squeeze of lime, and taste before adding more syrup. Orange juice is sweeter than lemon, so you may need less syrup.
If you have no citrus at all
Without any citrus, the drink loses its sour backbone. Whiskey with a sweetener and an egg white is a different style of drink. If you want a simple whiskey drink without citrus, try a highball or an Old Fashioned. See how to make a whisky highball or whiskey for cocktails.
Tips for a better no-lemon sour
- Use fresh juice. Bottled juice can taste flat.
- Shake hard with plenty of cold ice.
- Adjust one thing at a time. Start with less syrup, then add more if you need it.
- If you are out of simple syrup or other sweetener options, see what to use in place of sweet and sour mix.
Drink in moderation.