American Whiskey

Rye Whiskey vs Bourbon: Mash Bill, Spice and Which to Choose

Rye whiskey uses at least 51% rye and bourbon uses at least 51% corn. Rye usually tastes spicier and drier. Compare the mash bills, flavor and cocktails.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. The mash bill: the legal difference
  3. Flavor: spice vs sweetness
  4. Why the line blurs
  5. Cocktails: Manhattan, Old Fashioned, Sazerac
  6. Which to choose

Short answer

Rye whiskey is made from a mash of at least 51% rye. Bourbon is made from a mash of at least 51% corn. Rye usually tastes spicier and drier, while bourbon usually tastes sweeter and fuller. Both are aged in new charred oak and follow similar proof rules.

A mash bill is the grain recipe. For rye, the minimum is 51% rye grain. For bourbon, the minimum is 51% corn. The remaining grain can be corn, rye, wheat or malted barley, and the producer chooses the rest. The category sets a minimum, and the recipe fills in the rest.

Flavor: spice vs sweetness

Rye is often described with pepper, clove, herbal notes and a dry finish. Bourbon is often described with vanilla, caramel, brown sugar and sometimes fruit. These are common descriptions, not rules, and individual bottles vary.

Why the line blurs

Some bourbons use a high-rye mash bill, which can make them taste spicier than a corn-heavy bourbon. The label does not always state the mash bill, so check the producer’s information if the flavor matters to you. Rye and bourbon share many production rules, so the grain recipe is the main legal difference. For how “rye” is used on Canadian labels, see is Canadian whisky really rye.

Cocktails: Manhattan, Old Fashioned, Sazerac

Rye is traditional in the Sazerac and common in the Manhattan. Bourbon is common in the Old Fashioned and often works in a Manhattan too. Use the spirit that suits your taste, and try both if you are unsure. For rye picks by use, see the best rye whiskey.

Which to choose

  • Choose rye if you like spice, want a drier finish or are making a Sazerac.
  • Choose bourbon if you prefer caramel and vanilla or want a softer sip.
  • Taste both neat before you decide, since the spice and sweetness show more clearly without ice or mixers.

For more on the wider bourbon category, see bourbon vs whiskey. For a softer bourbon, see wheated bourbon.

The complete guide to american whiskey

Bourbon vs Whiskey: A Guide to American Whiskey
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →