Short answer
Maker’s Mark is softer and sweeter. Woodford Reserve is drier and spicier. Neither is better for everyone, so the right choice depends on what you want from a bourbon.
Mash bill: wheat vs rye
Maker’s Mark is a wheated bourbon. Its publicly listed mash bill is 70% corn, 16% red winter wheat and 14% malted barley. Woodford Reserve’s publicly listed mash bill is 72% corn, 18% rye and 10% malted barley. Wheat tends to give a softer, sweeter character. Rye tends to add spice and a drier finish.
Taste: soft and sweet vs spicy and oaky
Maker’s Mark is commonly described with soft caramel, vanilla and fruit, and less spice. Woodford Reserve is commonly described with more oak, baking spice, dried fruit and dark chocolate. These are common descriptions, and individual bottles and batches can vary.
Proof and strength
Standard Maker’s Mark is bottled at 90 proof (45% ABV). Standard Woodford Reserve is about 90 proof as well, so strength is not what separates them. Check the label on the bottle you buy, since bottlings can differ by market.
Which to choose
- A newcomer who wants softness: Maker’s Mark is often the easier starting point.
- An Old Fashioned or Manhattan with more structure: many people choose Woodford Reserve for its spice and oak.
- A gift: consider the recipient’s taste. A softer bourbon suits people who like sweetness, and a spicier one suits people who like bold flavors.
Opinions differ on which is better for newcomers. Some drinkers call Woodford Reserve smooth and approachable, and others find it harsher than Maker’s Mark. Taste both if you can.
Step-up bottles
- Maker’s Mark 46. A version of Maker’s Mark finished with seared French oak staves, which adds more flavor and a little more intensity.
- Woodford Reserve Double Oaked. A version finished in a second barrel, which adds oak and sweetness. See double barrel and cask-finished whiskey.
For another wheated option, see wheated bourbon. For a spicier comparison, see rye whiskey vs bourbon. For more bourbons people often name, see the ten most popular bourbons.