What “small batch” means
“Small batch” is a marketing term. No federal rule defines how many barrels go into a small batch, and no body checks the claim. A producer uses the words to describe a selection of barrels. The term tells you what the producer chooses to say, not a specific style or quality standard.
So treat a small batch label as a starting point. Read the proof, any age statement and the producer’s description before you decide.
How this shortlist was chosen
This is a selection, not a ranking. The title says “Top 10,” but taste is personal, and there is no official measure of the best bourbon. The ten bottles below were chosen because they are widely sold, carry small batch wording on the label at the time of writing, and cover a range of styles. Labels and recipes change, so check the bottle in front of you.
The ten bottles
Four Roses Small Batch
Listed at 90 proof. Four Roses makes its bourbons from several recipes, and the Small Batch is a blend of selected ones. Expect fruit and spice from the brand’s higher-rye recipes. For the whole lineup, see whether Four Roses is a good bourbon.
Basil Hayden’s
Listed at 80 proof. It is a high-rye bourbon with a lighter body than many. Its rye character often shows as light spice and a dry finish.
Knob Creek Small Batch
The Knob Creek Small Batch is aged nine years and listed at 100 proof. Expect caramel, toasted nut and oak, with a warm finish.
Booker’s
An uncut, unfiltered bourbon from Jim Beam. Proof varies by batch and is usually well above 100 proof, so each batch can taste different. For barrel-strength bottles in general, see barrel proof bourbon.
Elijah Craig Small Batch
A Heaven Hill bourbon. Expect caramel, vanilla and toasted oak, with a light spice. Heaven Hill’s range is covered in is Heaven Hill a good bourbon.
Larceny Small Batch
A wheated bourbon from Heaven Hill. Wheated bourbons usually taste softer and sweeter than high-rye ones. See wheated bourbon for more on the style.
Michter’s US*1 Small Batch
A bourbon from Michter’s, sold under its US*1 small batch label. Check the current proof on the bottle, since Michter’s has released several versions over time.
Jim Beam Small Batch
An everyday bourbon from Jim Beam, blended from several barrels and widely available. It is a common starting point for people who want a familiar, approachable pour.
Baker’s
A seven-year-old bourbon from Jim Beam’s small batch line. It is often listed at a higher proof than the standard Jim Beam, so check the label for the strength of the bottle you buy.
Russell’s Reserve Small Batch
A Wild Turkey small batch bourbon. The small batch wording has appeared on several Wild Turkey bottlings, so check the current label for the age and proof.
Which is the smoothest?
No single bottle is the smoothest for everyone. How smooth a bourbon feels depends on proof, mash bill, age and your own taste. A lower-proof bottle usually feels softer on the palate, though it can also taste thinner. A wheated bourbon often tastes softer than a high-rye one. Try two or three bottles side by side before you decide. For smooth picks beyond bourbon, see the top 10 smoothest whiskeys.
Buying tips
- Read the proof. Small batch bottles range from about 80 proof to well above 100 proof.
- Check the age statement. Some small batch bottles state an age, and many do not. See what NAS means on whisky.
- Expect batch variation. Recipes and proof can change, so a bottle you liked before may taste different now.
- Compare value by price per pour, not only the price of the bottle. For budget picks, see best value bourbons.
For a wider view of bottles people often name, see the ten most popular bourbons.