Short answer: no, but they start in a similar place
Unaged whiskey and vodka can both begin as grain spirit, and both come off the still clear. That similarity is why people ask the question. They are still different products. Unaged whiskey is distilled to keep its grain character, while vodka is distilled and often filtered to remove it.
How both begin
Both start with a fermented mash. For whiskey, that is usually a grain mash of corn, rye, wheat or barley. Vodka can be made from grain, potato or other starches. In both cases the mash is distilled into a high-strength spirit. The two paths diverge in how far the distiller goes to keep or strip out flavour.
Distillation strength
In the United States, the neutral spirit used for vodka is distilled to at least 190 proof (95% ABV). Whiskey must be distilled to less than 160 proof (80% ABV), which leaves more of the grain’s flavour compounds in the spirit. The strength at the still already points to two different outcomes.
Flavour goals
Vodka is made to be neutral. Distillers often filter it, for example through charcoal, to remove any remaining character. Unaged whiskey is made to keep the character of its grain and its fermentation. That is why it can taste sweet, cereal-like or sharp, while vodka is designed to taste close to neutral.
Legal definitions
US federal rules describe vodka as neutral and without distinctive character, aroma or taste. Whiskey is defined by its mash, its strength and, for aged styles, its barrels. A spirit with a clear grain character would generally be labelled as whiskey rather than vodka under those rules. For the strength and mash rules, see what a mash bill is.
Where the line blurs
Some unaged grain spirits are very light. In a cocktail, they can be hard to tell apart from vodka. The label and the legal category, not taste alone, decide which name applies. This is also why the still matters: column stills can produce very high-strength, lighter spirit, which is closer to vodka than a pot-distilled whiskey. See pot still vs column still whisky for how that works.
How to tell them apart
- Read the label. The category name, vodka or whiskey, and the grain, if stated, are the clearest guide.
- Smell the glass. Unaged whiskey usually has a grain, sweet or cereal aroma. Vodka is usually faint.
- Taste neat at room temperature. Unaged whiskey usually has more texture and flavour than vodka. The steps are in how to taste whisky.
For a fuller guide to unaged whiskey and its names, see unaged whiskey.
Mixing
In cocktails, the difference often matters less, because the other ingredients do most of the work. For a clean drink with little flavour, vodka is the usual choice. For a drink that wants a grain character, unaged whiskey can add something a neutral spirit cannot. For matching whiskey to classic drinks, see the best whiskey for cocktails.