Types of Whisky

Is whiskey or brandy better?

Whiskey or brandy? Neither is better overall. Here is how each spirit is made, how each tastes, and which to choose for sipping or cocktails.

On this page
  1. Short answer: neither is better overall
  2. What each spirit is made from
  3. How they taste
  4. Strength
  5. Which one for sipping
  6. Which one for cocktails
  7. A simple way to decide

Short answer: neither is better overall

Neither whiskey nor brandy is better in an absolute sense. They are different spirits, made from different raw materials, with different flavours. The better choice is the one you enjoy more, for the drink you want to make or the moment you are in.

What each spirit is made from

Whiskey is distilled from a fermented grain mash, usually barley, corn, rye or wheat. Most whiskeys are aged in wooden barrels, which add colour and flavour. Scotch, Irish whiskey, bourbon and rye are all whiskey.

Brandy is distilled from wine or fermented fruit. Grapes are the most common base. Cognac and Armagnac are grape brandies from France, and Calvados is an apple brandy from Normandy. Many brandies are also aged in oak.

For the main whisky styles, see the main types of whisky.

How they taste

Whiskey usually tastes grain-driven, with notes of caramel, vanilla, spice and oak. Peated Scotch adds smoke, and bourbon tends to be sweeter than rye. Brandy usually tastes fruitier and softer, with dried fruit, honey and floral aromas. Some drinkers find it rounder than whiskey.

Both can be oaky, so the ageing and the cask matter as much as the base spirit. A young brandy and an old whiskey can taste closer than their categories suggest.

Strength

Both spirits are often bottled near 40% ABV. Cask-strength whiskies can be much stronger, and some brandies are too. Strength alone does not decide which is better. Check the label for the bottling strength and for how the spirit was aged.

Which one for sipping

If you like rich, earthy or spicy flavours, whiskey is likely to suit you. If you prefer softer, fruitier notes, a brandy such as a Cognac or Armagnac may suit better. Pour a small measure of each at room temperature and notice whether you reach for fruit or for grain.

Which one for cocktails

Whiskey is the base for classics such as the Old Fashioned, the Manhattan and the whiskey sour. For which whiskey suits which drink, see the best whiskey for cocktails. Brandy is the base for drinks such as the Sidecar and the Brandy Alexander. The Pisco Sour uses pisco, a grape brandy.

A simple way to decide

Buy a small bottle of each in a similar price range, taste them side by side, and keep the one you enjoy. Price is not a reliable guide, since a premium brandy can cost much more than an everyday whiskey, and the reverse is also true. For the wider comparison with rum and vodka, see whiskey vs rum, brandy and vodka.

The complete guide to types of whisky

Know Your Whiskey: The Main Types of Whisky Explained
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →