The short answer
Neither is better in every case. A single malt is a whisky made from malted barley at one distillery. A blended whisky combines more than one whisky, usually from several distilleries. Which one you prefer depends on what you want from the glass. Single malts tend to show the character of their distillery, while blends are built for balance and consistency. A well-made blend can be as enjoyable as a single malt, and many single malts are themselves blends of casks from one distillery.
For the wider picture of Scotch and other styles, see the main types of whisky.
What single malt means
In Scotland, single malt has three defining features:
- It is made only from malted barley and water.
- It is made at a single distillery.
- It is distilled in pot stills.
“Single” refers to the distillery, not to one barrel. Most single malts combine casks from that distillery to keep a consistent house style. A bottle labelled “single cask” or “single barrel” comes from one cask. Single malts are also made outside Scotland, in Ireland, the United States, Japan and elsewhere, though the rules differ from country to country. For examples, see the best single malt Irish whiskey, American single malt whiskey and Japanese craft single malts.
What blended whisky means
Blended Scotch mixes malt whisky with grain whisky. Grain whisky is made from other cereals, such as wheat or corn, usually in column stills. The components often come from several distilleries. Johnnie Walker is a blended Scotch; see who owns Johnnie Walker. Blenders aim for a consistent flavour from one batch to the next, which is one reason blends are popular for mixing.
Vatted malt, or blended malt
A vatted malt is a blend of malt whiskies from more than one distillery, with no grain whisky. Current Scotch rules call this style blended malt, and some bottles still say “vatted malt”. The two terms describe the same kind of whisky.
Because it contains only malt, a blended malt builds its flavour from malt alone. Drinkers who want to explore malt character without committing to one distillery often use it as a middle step.
Is blended whisky worse?
Not as a rule. Single malt has a reputation as the premium choice, but that reputation rests partly on marketing and partly on personal taste. A well-balanced blend can be more consistent and more enjoyable than a young single malt, and a single malt can be less interesting than a good blend. Judge the bottle in front of you rather than the category alone.
Taste, price and when each suits you
A single malt suits you if you:
- want a distinctive, distillery-driven flavour;
- like to sip neat and notice how the whisky changes in the glass;
- are willing to pay more for a particular distillery or age.
A blended whisky suits you if you:
- want a smooth, balanced pour;
- mix whisky in cocktails or drink it on the rocks;
- want a consistent flavour from one bottle to the next.
Where Jack Daniel’s and other names fit
People often ask whether Jack Daniel’s is a malt. It is not. Jack Daniel’s is a Tennessee whiskey made from a mash that is mostly corn, so it is neither a single malt nor a blended Scotch. For more on its label, see whether Jack Daniel’s is a corn whiskey.
By contrast, Glenfiddich is a single malt Scotch from one distillery in Speyside, and it is a good example of the style. See Glenfiddich 12 vs The Glenlivet 12 for a closer look.
How to choose a first bottle
Start with what you plan to drink. For mixing, a blended whisky is often the more practical choice. For sipping, try a single malt and a blend side by side, neat, at room temperature. Notice whether you enjoy the distinctive character of one or the smoothness of the other. Then try different regions and ages as you go. For more on picking a bottle, see how to choose a whisky. For what the age on a label does and does not tell you, see what NAS means on whisky.