The short answer
Neither is objectively better. Bourbon is usually sweeter and rounder, while Scotch covers a wider range of flavours, from light and floral to smoky and peaty. The two are often described as opposites, but the difference is mostly one of style. Which one tastes better depends on what you enjoy.
How bourbon is made and tastes
Bourbon is an American whiskey. US rules require a grain mix of at least 51% corn, and it must be aged in new, charred oak containers. Those two rules explain much of its typical flavour. Corn gives a sweet, rounded base, and new charred oak adds vanilla, caramel and toasty notes. For the full rules, see bourbon vs whiskey.
Typical bourbon flavours include:
- Vanilla, caramel, toffee and brown sugar
- Oak and baking spice
- A fuller body, often with a sweet finish
How Scotch is made and tastes
Scotch is made in Scotland, and it must be matured in oak casks there for at least three years. Single malt Scotch is made from malted barley at one distillery. Blended Scotch mixes malt whisky with grain whisky. Many producers use casks that held bourbon or sherry, and those casks add their own notes. For regions and styles, see the Scotch whisky guide.
Scotch flavour varies widely by region and cask:
- Lighter styles often show fresh fruit, honey, floral or grassy notes.
- Sherry-matured styles often show dried fruit, nuts and spice.
- Peated styles, often from Islay, show smoke, iodine or medicinal notes, and some have a coastal, salty character.
Side by side
| Bourbon | Scotch | |
|---|---|---|
| Made in | United States | Scotland |
| Main grain | At least 51% corn | Malted barley (single malt), or malt and grain (blends) |
| Cask | New, charred oak | Oak casks, at least three years; often used casks |
| Typical flavour | Vanilla, caramel, oak spice | Very wide range, from fruity and floral to smoky |
| Typical feel | Full, round, often sweet | Varies: light and crisp, or rich and dry |
Which to try first
- If you like sweet, vanilla-led flavours, start with a bourbon.
- If you like variety, or you like smoke, start with a Scotch. A lighter Speyside is a gentle start; an Islay is bolder.
- If you want something in between, rye whiskey is usually spicier than bourbon, and Irish whiskey is often described as lighter and smoother.
Compare them yourself
Pour a small measure of each into the same kind of glass and taste them side by side. Note the sweetness, the spice, the body and the finish. Then ask which one you would order again.
For the steps, see how to taste whisky and describe its flavour. For the vocabulary to describe the differences, see the different types of whiskey tastes. If one of the two tastes too hot, a few drops of water can change the balance.