What a blind taste test shows
A blind taste test hides the labels, so you judge the liquid rather than the brand, age or price. It is a good way to check whether you can tell two whiskies apart, and whether your favourite is the one you expected. A few samples and a few tasters are not a scientific study, so treat the results as a guide to your own palate.
What you need
- Three or four whiskies that differ in style, such as a bourbon, a Speyside Scotch and a peated Islay. Very different strengths can skew the result, so note any cask-strength bottle.
- Identical glasses, one per sample, plus a spare for water. Clear tasting glasses work best.
- A pourer who knows the bottles and will not taste or comment. If you are alone, see the note below on hiding bottles.
- Still water and plain crackers or unsalted bread to clear the palate.
- The tasting sheet below, and a pen.
Keep the labels hidden
The pourer covers or removes the labels, numbers the glasses 1 to 4, and keeps the key sealed until scoring is done. Pour the same measure into each glass. Note which bottle is in which glass before you start.
If you are tasting alone, put each bottle in an opaque bag or cover it. Write the code list on paper, seal it in an envelope, and open it only after scoring.
The tasting sheet
Copy this table and fill it in for each sample.
| Glass | Nose | Palate | Finish | Score (1–10) | Guess (style or region) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||||
| 2 | |||||
| 3 | |||||
| 4 |
Score the whole dram, not each part, to keep it simple. Agree on what the numbers mean before you start, for example 5 for an average dram.
Running the tasting
- Taste lighter, lower-strength samples first, and leave the heaviest or strongest until last.
- Taste each sample neat, using the steps in how to taste whisky.
- Write notes before you score. Keep the nose, palate and finish separate. For the words to use, see the descriptors guide.
- Clear your palate with water and plain crackers, and wait a few minutes between samples.
- Score and guess. Once you have scored a sample, do not change it after you learn the labels.
Four samples is a reasonable limit for most people, since palates tire quickly.
For a stricter check, add a control: pour the same whisky twice. If the two scores differ a lot, the problem may be the setup or your palate rather than the whisky.
You can also run a triangle test. Pour three glasses: two from one bottle and one from another. Try to pick the odd one out. Guessing at random gets it right one time in three, so getting it right more often suggests you can tell the difference.
Reveal and compare
Reveal the bottles once every sheet is complete. Compare your scores and guesses, and ask what you were looking for. Did you pick the one you expected, or the one you liked most? Price and reputation shape expectations, and a blind test lets you see that.
Reading the results
- One tasting shows what you preferred that day, not which whisky is best overall.
- Repeat the test with different people or on a different day to see whether the result holds.
- If the scores are close, the whiskies may be similar to you. That is useful to know too.
To check whether price changes what you taste, read what expensive whiskey tastes like. If a whisky is harsh in a blind test, a splash of water can change the result, so keep the method the same for every sample.