Monkey Shoulder and Copper Dog are both blended malts from Speyside, sold at similar prices and often recommended for cocktails. They taste different, though, and the better choice depends on how you like to drink.
What a blended malt is
A blended malt combines single malts from more than one distillery and contains no grain whisky. Both of these bottles sit in that category, but the malts and the blending choices behind them differ.
Monkey Shoulder
- Maker: William Grant & Sons. For background, see who makes Monkey Shoulder Scotch.
- Style: A blend of Speyside single malts, aged in ex-bourbon casks, with no age statement.
- Strength: Listed at 43% ABV in the research, with 40% in some markets. Check your label.
- Price: Around $30 to $35 for a 750ml bottle in the US.
- Tasting notes: The nose shows orchard and citrus fruit, vanilla and honey. The palate is smooth and malty, with vanilla and mild spice. The finish is short to medium, clean and lightly sweet.
- Best for: Cocktails and easy sipping on the rocks. Reviewers also note a short finish and less depth than single malts.
Copper Dog
- Origin: Created in the mid-2010s by Piers Adam, owner of the Craigellachie Hotel in Speyside, with master blender Stuart Morrison.
- Name: It takes its name from the hotel’s pub and from the “copper dog”, a small copper tube that distillery workers used to draw samples from casks.
- Style: A blend of Speyside malts, with no age statement. The producer says it uses at least eight Speyside single malts. Bottled at 40% ABV.
- Price: Around $30 to $35 for a 750ml bottle in the US.
- Tasting notes: The nose shows ripe orchard fruit, honey, vanilla fudge and toffee. The palate is soft, malty and fruity, with toffee apple, caramel and gentle oak. The finish is light to medium, with sweet wood and honey.
- Best for: Easy drinking, on the rocks, with apple juice or cola, or in an Old Fashioned.
Side by side
| Monkey Shoulder | Copper Dog | |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Blended malt | Blended malt |
| Age statement | None | None |
| Strength | 43% listed; 40% in some markets | 40% |
| US price (750ml, approximate) | $30 to $35 | $30 to $35 |
| Main flavors | Citrus, orchard fruit, vanilla, honey | Orchard fruit, toffee, honey |
| Finish | Short to medium | Light to medium |
Which to choose
- Choose Monkey Shoulder if you want a brighter, citrus-leaning base for cocktails.
- Choose Copper Dog if you prefer a softer, toffee-and-apple style that’s easy to sip.
- Taste them side by side. Differences are easier to spot when you sip the two back to back.
For more on what a similarly priced bottle costs, see the price of Copper Dog Scotch. For other blends, see blended Scotch reviews.