Short answer: it depends on how you drink it
Neither is better for everyone. Jameson is often preferred for mixing, with a sweeter and rounder profile. Bushmills Original is often described as lighter and crisper, with more malt character, which some drinkers prefer for sipping. Taste tests give mixed results, so your own palate should make the call.
Quick comparison
| Jameson Original | Bushmills Original | |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Blended Irish whiskey | Blended Irish whiskey |
| Made at | New Midleton Distillery, County Cork | Old Bushmills Distillery, County Antrim, Northern Ireland |
| Strength | 40% ABV | 40% ABV |
| Typical profile | Sweet vanilla, orchard fruit, mild spice | Malty, crisp, drier finish |
| Often used for | Highballs and cocktails | Neat pours, on ice, lighter drinks |
Origin and production
Jameson is made at the New Midleton Distillery in County Cork, in the south of Ireland. It is a blend of pot still whiskey and grain whiskey. For more on the brand and its maker, see who makes Jameson.
Bushmills is made at the Old Bushmills Distillery in County Antrim, Northern Ireland. The distillery says its licence to distil dates to 1608, which is a point of pride for the brand. Bushmills Original is a blend of malt and grain whiskey. Northern Ireland is part of the island of Ireland, so Bushmills is an Irish whiskey in the same sense as Jameson.
Both are generally described as triple distilled.
Taste
Jameson is often described as sweeter, with vanilla, orchard fruit, toasted wood and a touch of spice. Bushmills is usually described as lighter and crisper, with malt, honey and a drier finish. Many people find Jameson milder and smoother, while others find Bushmills sharper. Your experience may differ.
Best uses
- Mixing: Jameson is a popular choice in highballs and classic cocktails, where its sweetness and spice hold up against ginger ale or other mixers.
- Neat or on ice: Bushmills suits drinkers who want a crisper, maltier sip.
What drinkers say
Opinions are mixed. In online whiskey communities, Jameson is often favored as a basic bottle, though some drinkers prefer Bushmills. Blind tests and forum threads give varied results, so the most useful test is a side-by-side with your own glass. For a fair setup, see how to run a whiskey blind taste test.
Old stereotypes that link either brand to religion are not a reliable guide to taste.
If you want to step up
- Jameson: variations on the blend, such as Black Barrel and Caskmates, change the flavor in different ways. Check the label for the exact expression.
- Bushmills: Black Bush is a bolder blend, and the Bushmills single malts, such as the 10 Year Old and 16 Year Old, are the next step for malt lovers.
For single malts in particular, see the best single malt Irish whiskey.
Which should you buy?
- Choose Jameson if you are making highballs or cocktails, or you want a sweeter, rounder bottle.
- Choose Bushmills if you want a crisper, maltier pour for neat sipping or on the rocks.
- If you can, try both neat and in a simple highball. The difference is easier to judge that way.